javascript - What is the fastest way to get multiple data-attributes from the same element - Stack Overflow

admin管理员组

文章数量:1026620

I have a use case which requires getting multiple html5 data-attributes from elements. This occurs within a loop across many elements and pushes the data in to an array for caching.

From doing some research it appears that using el.getAttribute('data-whatever') is faster than using the native html5 dataset method however I need to get around 5 separate data attributes from the same element.

The dataset method allows you to retrieve all data-attributes with one call and then access them with standard object dot notation ( dataset.index, dataset.whatever, dataset.somethingelse ) whereas using getAttribute I have to make repeated getAttribute calls to retrieve all the needed data.

If using non pliant attributes I can of course simply use dot notation to access the properties speeding up this function considerably. But using html5 data attributes this does not work (i.e. el.data-whatever will always be undefined).

I wish to remain pliant to standards therefore I am looking for the fastest possible way of retrieving these multiple data attributes.

Thanks in advance.

I have a use case which requires getting multiple html5 data-attributes from elements. This occurs within a loop across many elements and pushes the data in to an array for caching.

From doing some research it appears that using el.getAttribute('data-whatever') is faster than using the native html5 dataset method however I need to get around 5 separate data attributes from the same element.

The dataset method allows you to retrieve all data-attributes with one call and then access them with standard object dot notation ( dataset.index, dataset.whatever, dataset.somethingelse ) whereas using getAttribute I have to make repeated getAttribute calls to retrieve all the needed data.

If using non pliant attributes I can of course simply use dot notation to access the properties speeding up this function considerably. But using html5 data attributes this does not work (i.e. el.data-whatever will always be undefined).

I wish to remain pliant to standards therefore I am looking for the fastest possible way of retrieving these multiple data attributes.

Thanks in advance.

• javascript
• html

Share Improve this question Follow asked May 23, 2013 at 16:33 gordyrgordyr 6,2961414 gold badges6767 silver badges123123 bronze badges 3

• 2 You can make tests at jsperf. – Andreas Louv Commented May 23, 2013 at 16:35
• 1 It seems unlikely that fetching attributes from DOM nodes would be the focal point of performance. Have you profiled your code with Firefox or Chrome (or anything else) to look for "hot spots"? – Pointy Commented May 23, 2013 at 16:42
• @Pointy Yes I have profiled in detail. This is an extremely unusual use case and as such this kind of optimization is actual warranted. Thanks anyway :) – gordyr Commented May 23, 2013 at 16:49

Add a ment  | 

2 Answers 2

Sorted by: Reset to default 5

I made this test:

http://jsperf./dataset-vs-getattribute-2

The test is a the following:

dataset all:

var data = el.dataset;

getAttribute all:

var data = {
    id: el.getAttribute('data-id'),
    user: el.getAttribute('data-user'),
    dateOfBirth: el.getAttribute('data-date-of-birth')
};

dataset single:

var user = el.dataset.user;

getAttribute single:

var user = el.getAttribute('user');

https://developer.mozilla/en-US/docs/Web/API/element.dataset

Just benchmark it :

http://jsperf./dataset-access-vs-getattrb

It still looks to be 2 times faster using getAttribute on chrome.

I'm using a noop to prevent the JIT from optimizing it away.

I have a use case which requires getting multiple html5 data-attributes from elements. This occurs within a loop across many elements and pushes the data in to an array for caching.

From doing some research it appears that using el.getAttribute('data-whatever') is faster than using the native html5 dataset method however I need to get around 5 separate data attributes from the same element.

The dataset method allows you to retrieve all data-attributes with one call and then access them with standard object dot notation ( dataset.index, dataset.whatever, dataset.somethingelse ) whereas using getAttribute I have to make repeated getAttribute calls to retrieve all the needed data.

If using non pliant attributes I can of course simply use dot notation to access the properties speeding up this function considerably. But using html5 data attributes this does not work (i.e. el.data-whatever will always be undefined).

I wish to remain pliant to standards therefore I am looking for the fastest possible way of retrieving these multiple data attributes.

Thanks in advance.

I have a use case which requires getting multiple html5 data-attributes from elements. This occurs within a loop across many elements and pushes the data in to an array for caching.

From doing some research it appears that using el.getAttribute('data-whatever') is faster than using the native html5 dataset method however I need to get around 5 separate data attributes from the same element.

The dataset method allows you to retrieve all data-attributes with one call and then access them with standard object dot notation ( dataset.index, dataset.whatever, dataset.somethingelse ) whereas using getAttribute I have to make repeated getAttribute calls to retrieve all the needed data.

If using non pliant attributes I can of course simply use dot notation to access the properties speeding up this function considerably. But using html5 data attributes this does not work (i.e. el.data-whatever will always be undefined).

I wish to remain pliant to standards therefore I am looking for the fastest possible way of retrieving these multiple data attributes.

Thanks in advance.

• javascript
• html

Share Improve this question Follow asked May 23, 2013 at 16:33 gordyrgordyr 6,2961414 gold badges6767 silver badges123123 bronze badges 3

• 2 You can make tests at jsperf. – Andreas Louv Commented May 23, 2013 at 16:35
• 1 It seems unlikely that fetching attributes from DOM nodes would be the focal point of performance. Have you profiled your code with Firefox or Chrome (or anything else) to look for "hot spots"? – Pointy Commented May 23, 2013 at 16:42
• @Pointy Yes I have profiled in detail. This is an extremely unusual use case and as such this kind of optimization is actual warranted. Thanks anyway :) – gordyr Commented May 23, 2013 at 16:49

Add a ment  | 

2 Answers 2

Sorted by: Reset to default 5

I made this test:

http://jsperf./dataset-vs-getattribute-2

The test is a the following:

dataset all:

var data = el.dataset;

getAttribute all:

var data = {
    id: el.getAttribute('data-id'),
    user: el.getAttribute('data-user'),
    dateOfBirth: el.getAttribute('data-date-of-birth')
};

dataset single:

var user = el.dataset.user;

getAttribute single:

var user = el.getAttribute('user');

https://developer.mozilla/en-US/docs/Web/API/element.dataset

Just benchmark it :

http://jsperf./dataset-access-vs-getattrb

It still looks to be 2 times faster using getAttribute on chrome.

I'm using a noop to prevent the JIT from optimizing it away.

本文标签： javascriptWhat is the fastest way to get multiple dataattributes from the same elementStack Overflow