javascript - node.js and setTimeout and setInterval - understanding event loop - Stack Overflow

admin管理员组

文章数量:1023849

I have written the program below in efforts to understand the event-loop and functions like setTimeout and setInterval.

The output of the program is different from What I expected:

The output is:

In F
In L
Padalia
outside all
callback1
callback2
From Interval:0
From Interval:1
From Interval:2
From Interval:3

QUESTIONS:

1. Why is "oustside all" not execution first?
2. Why is the interval always executing last?
3. Can someone explain me the execution of the entire program.
4. Before exiting the program waits for sometime, why?

PROGRAM:

var Fname = undefined;
var Lname = undefined;
var count = 0;

function F(callback){
  console.log("In F");
  Fname = "Rushabh";
  if(Fname != undefined && Lname != undefined) { 
    console.log(Fname);
    }      
  process.nextTick(function() { 
    callback();
  });
//callback();
}

function L(callback){
  console.log("In L");
  Lname = "Padalia";
  if(Fname != undefined && Lname != undefined) { 
    console.log(Lname);
  } 
  process.nextTick(function() {callback();});
//callback();
} 

function pute(){

  Id = setInterval(function() {
    console.log("From Interval:" + count); count++;
    if(count > 3){
      clearInterval(Id);
    }
  }, 100)

 setTimeout(F(function(){
  console.log("callback1");
 }),5000);

 setTimeout(L(function(){
  console.log("callback2");
 }) , 5000);

 console.log("Outside all");
}

pute();

I have written the program below in efforts to understand the event-loop and functions like setTimeout and setInterval.

The output of the program is different from What I expected:

The output is:

In F
In L
Padalia
outside all
callback1
callback2
From Interval:0
From Interval:1
From Interval:2
From Interval:3

QUESTIONS:

1. Why is "oustside all" not execution first?
2. Why is the interval always executing last?
3. Can someone explain me the execution of the entire program.
4. Before exiting the program waits for sometime, why?

PROGRAM:

var Fname = undefined;
var Lname = undefined;
var count = 0;

function F(callback){
  console.log("In F");
  Fname = "Rushabh";
  if(Fname != undefined && Lname != undefined) { 
    console.log(Fname);
    }      
  process.nextTick(function() { 
    callback();
  });
//callback();
}

function L(callback){
  console.log("In L");
  Lname = "Padalia";
  if(Fname != undefined && Lname != undefined) { 
    console.log(Lname);
  } 
  process.nextTick(function() {callback();});
//callback();
} 

function pute(){

  Id = setInterval(function() {
    console.log("From Interval:" + count); count++;
    if(count > 3){
      clearInterval(Id);
    }
  }, 100)

 setTimeout(F(function(){
  console.log("callback1");
 }),5000);

 setTimeout(L(function(){
  console.log("callback2");
 }) , 5000);

 console.log("Outside all");
}

pute();

• javascript
• node.js
• asynchronous
• settimeout
• event-loop

Share Improve this question Follow edited Jun 14, 2013 at 6:48 Rushabh RajeshKumar Padalia asked Jun 14, 2013 at 6:20 Rushabh RajeshKumar PadaliaRushabh RajeshKumar Padalia 1,58122 gold badges1414 silver badges2828 bronze badges

Add a ment  | 

2 Answers 2

Sorted by: Reset to default 5

You have a bug in the code where you set F and L timeouts. Your code is equivalent to this:

/* ... */

F(function(){
  console.log("callback1");
});
setTimeout(undefined ,5000);

L(function(){
  console.log("callback2");
});
setTimeout(undefined, 5000);

/* ... */

Now it should be clear why your program does not behave as you were expecting:

1. "Outside all" is not executed first because you are calling F and L before.
2. The interval is executed last from the same reason.
3. The program waits 5 seconds for the two timeouts you set with undefined callback.

The easiest way how to fix your code is to add anonymous callback function for setTimeout calls:

 setTimeout(function() { F(function(){
  console.log("callback1");
 })},5000);

 setTimeout(function() { L(function(){
  console.log("callback2");
 })} , 5000);

Alternatively, you can use bind to fixate F and L parameters (the first parameter of bind is value for this):

setTimeout(F.bind(null, (function(){
 console.log("callback1");
})),5000);

setTimeout(L.bind(null, (function(){
 console.log("callback2");
})) , 5000);

You can also change your setTimeout as follows,

...
 setTimeout(F,5000,function(){
  console.log("callback1");
 });

 setTimeout(L,5000,function(){
  console.log("callback2");
 });
...

As setTimeout function won't take the parameter directly to your function, you need to send them in subsequent parameters.

setTimeout(function,milliseconds,param1,param2,...)

I have written the program below in efforts to understand the event-loop and functions like setTimeout and setInterval.

The output of the program is different from What I expected:

The output is:

In F
In L
Padalia
outside all
callback1
callback2
From Interval:0
From Interval:1
From Interval:2
From Interval:3

QUESTIONS:

1. Why is "oustside all" not execution first?
2. Why is the interval always executing last?
3. Can someone explain me the execution of the entire program.
4. Before exiting the program waits for sometime, why?

PROGRAM:

var Fname = undefined;
var Lname = undefined;
var count = 0;

function F(callback){
  console.log("In F");
  Fname = "Rushabh";
  if(Fname != undefined && Lname != undefined) { 
    console.log(Fname);
    }      
  process.nextTick(function() { 
    callback();
  });
//callback();
}

function L(callback){
  console.log("In L");
  Lname = "Padalia";
  if(Fname != undefined && Lname != undefined) { 
    console.log(Lname);
  } 
  process.nextTick(function() {callback();});
//callback();
} 

function pute(){

  Id = setInterval(function() {
    console.log("From Interval:" + count); count++;
    if(count > 3){
      clearInterval(Id);
    }
  }, 100)

 setTimeout(F(function(){
  console.log("callback1");
 }),5000);

 setTimeout(L(function(){
  console.log("callback2");
 }) , 5000);

 console.log("Outside all");
}

pute();

I have written the program below in efforts to understand the event-loop and functions like setTimeout and setInterval.

The output of the program is different from What I expected:

The output is:

In F
In L
Padalia
outside all
callback1
callback2
From Interval:0
From Interval:1
From Interval:2
From Interval:3

QUESTIONS:

1. Why is "oustside all" not execution first?
2. Why is the interval always executing last?
3. Can someone explain me the execution of the entire program.
4. Before exiting the program waits for sometime, why?

PROGRAM:

var Fname = undefined;
var Lname = undefined;
var count = 0;

function F(callback){
  console.log("In F");
  Fname = "Rushabh";
  if(Fname != undefined && Lname != undefined) { 
    console.log(Fname);
    }      
  process.nextTick(function() { 
    callback();
  });
//callback();
}

function L(callback){
  console.log("In L");
  Lname = "Padalia";
  if(Fname != undefined && Lname != undefined) { 
    console.log(Lname);
  } 
  process.nextTick(function() {callback();});
//callback();
} 

function pute(){

  Id = setInterval(function() {
    console.log("From Interval:" + count); count++;
    if(count > 3){
      clearInterval(Id);
    }
  }, 100)

 setTimeout(F(function(){
  console.log("callback1");
 }),5000);

 setTimeout(L(function(){
  console.log("callback2");
 }) , 5000);

 console.log("Outside all");
}

pute();

• javascript
• node.js
• asynchronous
• settimeout
• event-loop

Share Improve this question Follow edited Jun 14, 2013 at 6:48 Rushabh RajeshKumar Padalia asked Jun 14, 2013 at 6:20 Rushabh RajeshKumar PadaliaRushabh RajeshKumar Padalia 1,58122 gold badges1414 silver badges2828 bronze badges

Add a ment  | 

2 Answers 2

Sorted by: Reset to default 5

You have a bug in the code where you set F and L timeouts. Your code is equivalent to this:

/* ... */

F(function(){
  console.log("callback1");
});
setTimeout(undefined ,5000);

L(function(){
  console.log("callback2");
});
setTimeout(undefined, 5000);

/* ... */

Now it should be clear why your program does not behave as you were expecting:

1. "Outside all" is not executed first because you are calling F and L before.
2. The interval is executed last from the same reason.
3. The program waits 5 seconds for the two timeouts you set with undefined callback.

The easiest way how to fix your code is to add anonymous callback function for setTimeout calls:

 setTimeout(function() { F(function(){
  console.log("callback1");
 })},5000);

 setTimeout(function() { L(function(){
  console.log("callback2");
 })} , 5000);

Alternatively, you can use bind to fixate F and L parameters (the first parameter of bind is value for this):

setTimeout(F.bind(null, (function(){
 console.log("callback1");
})),5000);

setTimeout(L.bind(null, (function(){
 console.log("callback2");
})) , 5000);

You can also change your setTimeout as follows,

...
 setTimeout(F,5000,function(){
  console.log("callback1");
 });

 setTimeout(L,5000,function(){
  console.log("callback2");
 });
...

As setTimeout function won't take the parameter directly to your function, you need to send them in subsequent parameters.

setTimeout(function,milliseconds,param1,param2,...)

本文标签： javascriptnodejs and setTimeout and setIntervalunderstanding event loopStack Overflow