javascript - Protractor, with isDisplayed() I get NoSuchElementError: No element found using locator - Stack Overflow

admin管理员组

文章数量:1130349

In protractor 2.0, I am checking in a expect() if one element is displayed. I expect a false, but the weird thing is that I get following error:

NoSuchElementError: No element found using locator: By.id("userForm")

My code is:

describe('closeModal', function() {
    it('should close the alert that appears after registration.', function(){
        element(by.id('closeAlertModalButton')).click();
        expect(element(by.id('userForm')).isDisplayed()).toBeFalsy();
    });
});

I understand that I get that error because element is not longer on the page (is what I want to confirm), but shouldn't I get a false and not a error?

In protractor 2.0, I am checking in a expect() if one element is displayed. I expect a false, but the weird thing is that I get following error:

NoSuchElementError: No element found using locator: By.id("userForm")

My code is:

describe('closeModal', function() {
    it('should close the alert that appears after registration.', function(){
        element(by.id('closeAlertModalButton')).click();
        expect(element(by.id('userForm')).isDisplayed()).toBeFalsy();
    });
});

I understand that I get that error because element is not longer on the page (is what I want to confirm), but shouldn't I get a false and not a error?

• javascript
• angularjs
• jasmine
• protractor
• angularjs-e2e

Share Improve this question Follow asked May 7, 2015 at 11:35 MikelMikel 6,20255 gold badges3636 silver badges5050 bronze badges 1

• You should better use isElementPresent or isPresent - error you've got is part of WebDriver logic – Vasiliy vvscode Vanchuk Commented May 7, 2015 at 11:39

Add a comment  | 

4 Answers 4

Sorted by: Reset to default 36

isDisplayed() would check if an element is visible or not, but you need to check whether an element is present in DOM or not, use isElementPresent() or isPresent():

expect(browser.isElementPresent(element(by.id('userForm')))).toBe(false);
expect(element(by.id('userForm')).isPresent()).toBe(false);

See also:

• How do I test if an img tag exists?
• Use element by css to check if element exists in Protractor

This error is part of WebDriver behavior. For such cases you should better use isPresent or isElementPresent

If element visible do A if not visible do B, disregard exception if element not found:

element.isDisplayed().then(function(visible){
    if (visible) {
        // do A when element visible
    }else{
        // do B when element not visible 
    }
}, function () {
    //suppress exception if element is not found on page
});

.isDisplayed() assumes the element is present (exists in the DOM)

so if you do

expect($('[ng-show=saving]').isDisplayed()).toBe(true);

but the element is not present, then instead of graceful failed expectation, $('[ng-show=saving]').isDisplayed() will throw an error causing the rest of it block not executed

Solution

If you assume, the element you're checking may not be present for any reason on the page, then go with a safe way below

/**
*  element is Present and is Displayed
*  @param    {ElementFinder}      $element       Locator of element
*  @return   {boolean}
*/
let isDisplayed = function ($element) {
  return (await $element.isPresent()) && (await $element.isDisplayed())
}

and use

expect(await isDisplayed( $('[ng-show=saving]') )).toBe(true);

In protractor 2.0, I am checking in a expect() if one element is displayed. I expect a false, but the weird thing is that I get following error:

NoSuchElementError: No element found using locator: By.id("userForm")

My code is:

describe('closeModal', function() {
    it('should close the alert that appears after registration.', function(){
        element(by.id('closeAlertModalButton')).click();
        expect(element(by.id('userForm')).isDisplayed()).toBeFalsy();
    });
});

I understand that I get that error because element is not longer on the page (is what I want to confirm), but shouldn't I get a false and not a error?

In protractor 2.0, I am checking in a expect() if one element is displayed. I expect a false, but the weird thing is that I get following error:

NoSuchElementError: No element found using locator: By.id("userForm")

My code is:

describe('closeModal', function() {
    it('should close the alert that appears after registration.', function(){
        element(by.id('closeAlertModalButton')).click();
        expect(element(by.id('userForm')).isDisplayed()).toBeFalsy();
    });
});

I understand that I get that error because element is not longer on the page (is what I want to confirm), but shouldn't I get a false and not a error?

• javascript
• angularjs
• jasmine
• protractor
• angularjs-e2e

Share Improve this question Follow asked May 7, 2015 at 11:35 MikelMikel 6,20255 gold badges3636 silver badges5050 bronze badges 1

• You should better use isElementPresent or isPresent - error you've got is part of WebDriver logic – Vasiliy vvscode Vanchuk Commented May 7, 2015 at 11:39

Add a comment  | 

4 Answers 4

Sorted by: Reset to default 36

isDisplayed() would check if an element is visible or not, but you need to check whether an element is present in DOM or not, use isElementPresent() or isPresent():

expect(browser.isElementPresent(element(by.id('userForm')))).toBe(false);
expect(element(by.id('userForm')).isPresent()).toBe(false);

See also:

• How do I test if an img tag exists?
• Use element by css to check if element exists in Protractor

This error is part of WebDriver behavior. For such cases you should better use isPresent or isElementPresent

If element visible do A if not visible do B, disregard exception if element not found:

element.isDisplayed().then(function(visible){
    if (visible) {
        // do A when element visible
    }else{
        // do B when element not visible 
    }
}, function () {
    //suppress exception if element is not found on page
});

.isDisplayed() assumes the element is present (exists in the DOM)

so if you do

expect($('[ng-show=saving]').isDisplayed()).toBe(true);

but the element is not present, then instead of graceful failed expectation, $('[ng-show=saving]').isDisplayed() will throw an error causing the rest of it block not executed

Solution

If you assume, the element you're checking may not be present for any reason on the page, then go with a safe way below

/**
*  element is Present and is Displayed
*  @param    {ElementFinder}      $element       Locator of element
*  @return   {boolean}
*/
let isDisplayed = function ($element) {
  return (await $element.isPresent()) && (await $element.isDisplayed())
}

and use

expect(await isDisplayed( $('[ng-show=saving]') )).toBe(true);

本文标签：